Two Court Defeats in a Week for Poland’s Justice Minister as Supreme Court Defends Judicial Independence

  • On July 2, 2026, Poland’s Supreme Court (Supreme Court) overturned the order of Minister of Justice Waldemar Żurek imposing an immediate break in the official duties of Judge Łukasz Piebiak, a member of the National Council of the Judiciary (NCJ), finding that it had no justified grounds.
  • The Supreme Court thereby confirmed the assessment we have presented from the outset: the conditions of Article 130 § 1 of the Law on the System of Common Courts were not met, and the Minister’s decision was an act of repression for the judge’s protest against the questionable actions of the new NCJ.
  • This is not the Minister’s last defeat before the Supreme Court — on July 7, 2026, the Supreme Court also refused to waive the immunity of Judge Piotr Schab, the Disciplinary Prosecutor for Judges of the Common Courts, in a case concerning the alleged defamation of Waldemar Żurek.

On July 2, 2026, Poland’s Supreme Court overturned the order of Minister of Justice Waldemar Żurek of June 15 immediately suspending from official duties Judge Łukasz Piebiak, who is also a member of the NCJ. As the presiding judge, Judge Marek Siwek, stated, the order “has no justified grounds” and does not meet the conditions laid down in the Law on the System of Common Courts.

Let us recall the context: the order was issued just days after Judge Piebiak — elected to the Council without the backing of the ruling majority — protested against the political resolution of the new NCJ, in which the Council groundlessly challenged the mandate of its own previous composition, and against the Council’s endorsement of the Minister’s unlawful narrative about the dismissal of the Disciplinary Prosecutor, Judge Piotr Schab. The Presidium of the NCJ — without any legal basis whatsoever — also suspended the judge’s access to the Council’s documents.

The Supreme Court confirmed: the conditions of Article 130 § 1 were not met

As we have already written earlier, Article 130 § 1 of the Law on the System of Common Courts allows a break in a judge’s duties to be ordered only where a judge is caught in the act of committing an intentional crime, or where the authority of the court or the essential interests of the service require his immediate removal from duties. Meanwhile, the Minister relied on two proceedings that have been pending for a long time, in which nothing new has happened. Judge Siwek agreed with this assessment, indicating that the notion of “immediacy” must be linked:

with the fact that an act has been committed which requires an immediate reaction that, moreover, cannot be undertaken in any other procedure.

Meanwhile, none of the circumstances indicated by the Minister belongs to this category, as was expressly emphasized by the adjudicating panel. It was also indicated that the matters allowing the Minister to reach for such a drastic measure must, on the one hand, be of truly serious weight and, on the other, must not raise significant doubts:

without any special evidentiary proceedings, every citizen can assess that they are so reprehensible that no judge may, immediately after committing them, continue to perform official duties.

Meanwhile, in both cases invoked by the Minister, the proceedings have been pending for many years and are still far from being fully clarified.

Judge Siwek also emphasized that:

it follows from the very principle of the separation of powers that if there is to be any interference by the executive in the judiciary, it must by its very nature be treated as exceptional.

The judge also pointed out that the Minister’s sudden decision is all the more incomprehensible given that, in one of the cases, the date of the next hearing has already been set and is to take place relatively soon — on August 6, 2026.

In light of the Supreme Court’s ruling, any attempt to restrict Judge Piebiak’s powers as a member of the NCJ thus loses even the last vestiges of an appearance of legality — already highly questionable before.

Another defeat for the Minister: the Supreme Court refused to waive Judge Schab’s immunity

The Supreme Court’s decision in the above case is not the end of the bad news for the Minister of Justice. On July 7, 2026, the Supreme Court refused to waive the immunity of Judge Piotr Schab in a case concerning the alleged defamation of Waldemar Żurek at a press conference in May 2022. Judge Schab — as the Disciplinary Prosecutor for Judges of the Common Courts — was at the time providing information about disciplinary charges concerning false dates of issuance given on rulings signed by then-Judge Żurek, which, in the latter’s view, defamed him. Although the offense of defamation referred to in Article 212 of the Criminal Code is prosecuted by private indictment, the public prosecutor unexpectedly decided to join the case. The motion to waive the immunity was submitted to the Supreme Court in January of this year by the Internal Affairs Division of the National Prosecutor’s Office — that is, a unit subordinate to the Prosecutor General, who is… Waldemar Żurek himself. From the beginning of the case, one could therefore have the impression that public bodies were being engaged for entirely private purposes — which the Veritas Et Ius in the Service of the Nation Lawyer’s Association described outright as:

Self-interest in the service of the state.

Although the presiding judge — Zbigniew Korzeniowski — found that Judge Schab’s statements from 2022 were not justified, he nonetheless refused to waive the immunity, holding that the judge’s statement falls within the scope of an error of law.

The Supreme Court’s decision is all the more significant because it was issued in the very middle of the dispute over who holds the office of Disciplinary Prosecutor for Judges of the Common Courts, which we have been documenting for many months. Let us recall its main stages. In April 2025, Minister Adam Bodnar announced the “dismissal” of Judge Schab from the office of Disciplinary Prosecutor, even though no provision of law allowed it. In September 2025, his successor, Minister Żurek, announced the appointment of Judge Joanna Raczkowska to the allegedly vacated office. Meanwhile, the Supreme Court, in a consistent line of case law — culminating in the decision of December 8, 2025 in case II ZOW 80/22 — refused to recognize the legality of those decisions, recalling that, in light of Article 7 of the Constitution, the competences of public authorities cannot be presumed, and public bodies may not act unless a statute expressly authorizes them to do so.

Although Judge Schab’s four-year term expired on June 4, 2026, nevertheless under Article 112 § 5 of the Law on the System of Common Courts the Prosecutor performs his duties:

until the appointment of the persons performing these functions in the next term.

The Minister could therefore now fully lawfully appoint a successor — but he would thereby have to admit that his actions to date, including the “appointment” of Judge Raczkowska, were unlawful. Instead, the Minister obtained the support of the new composition of the NCJ, which at its first sitting on June 11, 2026 adopted a counterfactual position recognizing the effectiveness of his decisions — based on the reasoning that “whoever may appoint may also dismiss”, which Poland’s Constitutional Tribunal already rejected in its resolution of May 10, 1994 in case W 7/94. A few days later, the new Chairman of the NCJ withdrew the Prosecutor’s and his deputies’ access rights to the premises of the Council’s seat — without giving any legal basis whatsoever.

It is at this point that the two cases above converge: it was precisely against this position of the NCJ that Judge Łukasz Piebiak protested at the Council’s sitting, stressing that it is for the judicial authorities, not the NCJ, to decide who is the Disciplinary Prosecutor, and that the Council was exposing itself to liability for damages. A few days later, Minister Żurek ordered a break in his official duties. The Minister’s actions thus formed a very clear sequence of events.

With regard to this thread, in its resolution of July 7 the Supreme Court did not determine who currently holds the office of disciplinary prosecutor for judges of the common courts. It stated, however, that this must be resolved by:

some authority.

Nevertheless, it described the actions of the Minister, who did not inform the court about the appointments to and dismissal from this office, as a “strange situation”.

Summary

Within a single week, the Minister of Justice lost twice before the Supreme Court: in the case of Judge Piebiak and in the case of Judge Schab. In both, the Supreme Court stood on the same elementary principle: in a state governed by the rule of law, an organ of executive power acts on the basis of, and within the limits of, the law (Article 7 of the Constitution), not on the basis of the political need of the moment. All of the above clearly indicates that the actions of the Minister and the circles supporting him have nothing to do with actually restoring the rule of law, but constitute nothing more than tools of political revenge against the judges who protest most loudly against the unlawful actions of the current Minister and his predecessor. One can only hope that these abuses, too, will in due course be duly accounted for.

Source of illustration: iStock.

Cookie settings
Rule of law observer

Decide which cookies you want to enable. Remember that limiting cookies may block the use of some functions. For information on deleting cookies, please refer to the help function in your browser.

Necessary

These are cookies that store information about the selection of cookie settings and user sessions, cookies related to security mechanisms and support for forms and experimental functions.

Analytics

These cookies support analytical mechanisms that track visited pages and interactions, track time spent on the site and increase the quality of data of statistical functions.

Marketing

These cookies help us track the effectiveness of our marketing campaigns. Enabling these cookies helps us better tailor our advertised campaigns to our audience.